
9/13/2011 – Slovak President shamefully calls Janos Esterhazy, a hero of the Holocaust, a follower of Hitler. AHF continues call for rehabilitation of Janos Esterhazy, reacts to Slovak falsification of history…
![[Comment] on Politics.hu](/wp-content/uploads/legacy/images/logo_politics-hu.gif)
Read the article and [Comment] on Politics.hu
Stalin, who in 1948 extended his empire to include Czechoslovakia, was a master of historical falsification, as best evidenced by his orders to blame the Germans, who were nowhere near the site, for the Katyn Forest massacre of Polish officers and other prisoners in 1940. The peoples of Central and Eastern Europe shook off their communist masters more than twenty years ago, which lead to the disintegration of the Soviet empire. Old practices like the falsification of the past and intolerance toward minorities, however, die hard, as events in Slovakia, a NATO and European Union member, recently demonstrated.

[download] the Politics.hu article: “Falsification of History in Slovakia”
Ivan Gasparovic, President of Slovakia and a former prosecutor under the communist regime, resorted to this shameful practice when he labeled Janos Esterhazy a follower of Hitler and fascism and opposed the unveiling of a sculpture in Esterhazy’s memory in Kassa (Kosice), a city close to Slovakia’s border with Hungary. Gasparovic’s statement is historically indefensible and serves to fan the flames of ethnic hatred and intolerant nationalism in Slovakia.
In 1938, Hungary regained part of Czechoslovakia inhabited predominantly by ethnic Hungarians. Fewer than 100,000 Hungarians remained in Slovakia, an ally and client state of Nazi Germany between 1939 and 1945.
Although Esterhazy could have left Slovakia and taken a seat in Hungary’s parliament, he chose instead to stay to serve the small Hungarian community remaining in Slovakia as the head of the Hungarian Party. In that capacity, Esterhazy opposed the Slovak Nazi puppet regime of Jozef Tiso. At great peril to himself, he was the only member of the Slovak Parliament to vote against the law authorizing the deportation of Jews in 1942. Later, Esterhazy personally saved Jews from the Holocaust.
Not surprisingly Esterhazy’s and his party’s anti-fascist stand did not sit well with the Nazis. He was pursued by the Gestapo and went into hiding, choosing once again to stay with his community in Slovakia instead of going into exile.
Immediately after the war in 1945, Esterhazy was arrested on the orders of Gustav Husak, a post-war communist leader of Czechoslovakia, for speaking out against the discriminatory anti-Hungarian measures introduced by the government. These measures, rooted in the anti-democratic concept of collective guilt, stripped ethnic Hungarians of their citizenship, virtually all of their rights, property (without compensation), dignity, and, in some cases, their lives. After being handed over to the KGB, Esterhazy was convicted as a “war criminal” by a Soviet court.
In 1947, while Esterhazy was imprisoned in the Soviet Union, the National Court in Slovakia in a perfunctory proceeding, and without any evidence, sentenced him to death in absentia on the trumped up charges of being a fascist and having contributed to the dissolution of Czechoslovakia. It is a cruel irony that Esterhazy was wrongly accused of doing exactly what Slovakia would do on its own forty-six years later in the “Velvet Divorce” of 1993 — dissolving Czechoslovakia. Upon his return from Russia, Esterhazy’s sentence was commuted to life in prison. He died in a Czechoslovak prison in 1957 and was buried in an undisclosed mass grave.
It was more than reasonable to expect Slovakia to exonerate Esterhazy, an unsung hero of anti-Nazi resistance, after the demise of communism. Even Russia exonerated him on January 21, 1993, acknowledging that he had been “arrested without cause.” Astonishingly, however, Slovakia still refuses to exonerate him. This despite the irrefutable historical record of Esterhazy’s principled anti-fascist views and actions, the pleas of the Hungarian minority and his family, and support from internationally recognized individuals such as Simon Wiesenthal who wrote on behalf of Esterhazy to Dr. Peter Samko, Chief Judge of the Bratislava Court. Slovakia is even failing to take into account that the Catholic Church has begun the process to beatify Esterhazy.
Not only is President Gasparovic’s statement a falsification of history, it dishonors a man of integrity and courage, is a slap in the face to Slovakia’s Hungarian minority and, hence, has become a source of tension between Hungary and Slovakia. Esterhazy’s posthumous exoneration, on the other hand, would constitute a long overdue act of reconciliation, which would lead to improved relations between two NATO allies as well as serve the cause of truth and justice.
Frank Koszorus, Jr., a lawyer, is President of the American Hungarian Federation.
AHF REMEMBERS THE HEROES OF THE HUNGARIAN HOLOCAUST
The Federation takes this opportunity to remember Carl Lutz, Raoul Wallenberg and other foreign diplomats as well as the Hungarian heroes who at great personal peril saved many Jewish lives. The Hungarians include but, of course, are not limited to the following individuals:
- Janos Esterhazy opposed the Slovak Nazi puppet regime of Jozef Tiso. At great peril to himself, he was the only member of the Slovak Parliament to vote against the law authorizing the deportation of Jews in 1942. Later, Esterhazy personally saved Jews from the Holocaust. Later, Esterhazy personally saved Jews from the Holocaust. He was detained by the Nazis and died in a communist prison. He is still classified as a war criminal in Slovakia and shamefully called a follower of Hitler in 2011 by the Slovak President. On November 3, 2011, the Anti-Defamation League presented the Jan Karski Courage to Care Award posthumously to Esterhazy.
- General Vilmos Nagybaczoni-Nagy who upon being appointed minister of defense by the Kallay government took measures to end the gross abuse threatening the lives of Jews and others in the auxiliary labor force;
- Tibor Baranszky who, as secretary to Monsignor Angelo Rotta, the Vatican’s ambassador to Budapest, saved many lives by distributing protective letters to Jews on forced marches and elsewhere;
- Roman Catholic Priest Ferenc Kallo who gave Jews life‐saving certificates of baptism and who was killed by the Arrow Cross on October 29, 1944;
- Jozsef Antall Senior, who as a member of the ministry of internal affairs for civilian refugees
gave refuge to and thereby saved Jews and Poles and who enjoyed the support and confidence of Minister of Interior Ferenc Keresztes‐Fischer and Prime Ministers Pal Teleki and after his death Miklos Kallay. - Istvan Bethlen who communicated protests to Regent Horthy in 1944 against deportations following Nazi Germany’s occupation of Hungary; and
- Col. Ferenc Koszorus, posthumously promoted to the rank of General by Prime Minister Antall after the fall of Communism, who volunteered his services and mobilized the 1st Armored Division under his command to militarily intervene on July 5, 1944 to stop Laszlo Baky, a secretary of state in the Ministry of Interior for “Jewish Affairs,” from deporting the approximately 200,000 plus Jews from Budapest.
A Few Related Articles

6/30/2009 – Use of Hungarian ILLEGAL in Slovakia… Hungary’s Foreign Ministry expressed regret and concern over the amendment to Slovakia’s act on its official language approved in parliament on Tuesday. Under the amended act the use of the minority language in official communication would be punishable in towns and villages where the ethnic community makes up less than 20 percent of the total population. [read more]

11/8/2011 – The Anti-Defamation League presented the Jan Karski Courage to Care Award to Count Janos Esterhazy. This comes just two months after the Slovak President shamefully calls this hero of the Holocaust a follower of Hitler. AHF continues to express concern over Slovakia’s anti-Hungarian measures. “Those who defended and aided Jews and other victims of the Nazi slaughter merit our recognition and our eternal thanks. They were individuals who followed the call to conscience, which is surely no simple matter… Count János Esterházy was such a person of conscience, one who had more than enough reason to remain silent.” [read more]

12/02/2011 – Slovakia strips citizenship of ethnic Hungarian minorties. AHF submits a statement to the US Congress Helsinki Commission: “Intolerance and discrimination targeting any group based on ethnicity, nationality or religion is not acceptable… The most recent anti-Hungarian incident involves Slovakia stripping Oliver Boldoghy of his Slovak citizenship after becoming a dual citizen. This decision is not only contrary to American and European practices, it violates the Slovak constitution, which provides that “no one must be deprived of the citizenship of the Slovak Republic against his will.” [read more]


3/23/2011 – AHF honors Col. Ferenc Koszorus, Sr., reflects on Holocaust Memorial Month. AHF honors the millions of lives lost and the untold suffering caused by Nazism and Communism. But even during the horrors of WWII, stories of resistance to Nazi atrocities emerged.
Hungary, heavily influenced by her desire to regain lost territories and reunite Hungarians in the Carpathian Basin, had found support in Italy and Germany and joined the Axis, a tragic mistake. [read more]

10/20/2007 – Slovaks confirm Benes Decrees: “Hungarians are the cancer of the Slovak nation, without delay we need to remove them from the body of the nation” – Jan Slota. AHF releases statement on the Benes Decrees and recent extremist developments in Slovakia. “Having taken a step that has fueled ethnic hatred and assaulted good relations with Hungary, the Slovak Parliament on September 20, 2007 adopted a resolution proposed by extremist Jan Slota ratifying and confirming the Benes decrees. Those decrees shamefully imposed collective guilt on the Hungarian (and German) population of Czechoslovakia in 1945 and stripped them of their citizenship, rights and property without compensation. Czechoslovakia also pursued a policy of ethnic cleansing in southern Slovakia. The debilitations continue to affect many of the victims of the crimes committed in post-World War II Czechoslovakia.

The concept of collective guilt is abhorrent to Americans and to anyone committed to the rule of law, human rights and democracy. Rather than affirm the inviolability of the Benes decrees, Slovakia should reject them, provide legal redress to remedy their continuing and discriminatory effect and thereby adopt the values shared by the trans-Atlantic community of nations. [read more]
[<< back to News from Slovakia]
Related
“The Slovak government has strayed onto a dangerous path when it submitted the bill about expelling the Jewish, because by that it acknowledged that simply ousting a minority by the majority is lawful… As a representative of the Hungarians here, I state it, and please acknowledge this, that I don’t vote in favour of the proposal because as a Hungarian, a Christian and a Catholic I believe that this is against God and humanity.” – Count János Esterházy
Briefly about Janos Esterhazy

A Proud Aristocratic Tradition
Count János Esterházy (Nyitraújlak, Austria-Hungary, March 14, 1901 – Czechoslovakia, March 8, 1957) a member of the House of Esterházy was the most prominent ethnic Hungarian politician in former Czechoslovakia. He was four when his father died. He went to secondary school in Budapest and after studying commerce he returned to his estate in an area which Hungary was forced to cede to Czechoslovakia in the Treaty of Trianon which closed World War I. In 1935, He was elected to parliament in Kassa (Košice). In his first speech in parliament he said: “As we have been attached to Czechoslovakia against our will, we demand that the Czechoslovak government fully respect our minority, language, cultural and economic rights.” He also supported the claims of ethnic Hungarians for autonomy within Slovakia. This made him a target for Czechoslovak authorities.
The Courage of Conviction
He was the only member of the Slovak Parliament in 1942 who voted against expelling the Jews, setting an example which few dared to follow in the parts of Europe controlled by Adolf Hitler’s Germany. He was detained by the Nazis and died in a communist prison. Officially he is still classified as a war criminal in Slovakia, as courts have rejected requests for his rehabilitation.
On May 15, 1942, the Slovak parliament approved constitutional law 68/1942 ordering the expulsion of Jews from Slovakia. Esterházy was the only MP who voted against the bill and he immediately became the target of fierce attacks in the Slovak press. To defend his views, he said:
“The Slovak government has strayed onto a dangerous path when it submitted the bill about expelling the Jewish, because by that it acknowledged that simply ousting a minority by the majority is lawful… As a representative of the Hungarians here, I state it, and please acknowledge this, that I don’t vote in favour of the proposal because as a Hungarian, a Christian and a Catholic I believe that this is against God and humanity.”
He also declared:
“It is shameful that a government, whose president and prime minister claim to be good Catholics, deports its Jewish citizens to Hitler’s concentration camps”
János Esterházy helped hundreds of Jewish, Czechs, Slovaks and Poles escape prosecution. He was interned for a short period and the German Gestapo declared him wanted. Here is a quote from Irén Rujder, widow of Ödön Rujder’s a Jew who was rescued by Esterházy:
“We all, who lived in Slovakia in that time, know the truth. They (the Czechoslovaks) handed him (Esterházy) to the Soviets, because if they had brought him to justice in Bratislava, all of the Jews would have testified his innocence. The misinterpretation of truth like this is painful, Esterházy really deserves the true tree of Israel.”
A Tragic Life and DeathAfter the Soviet army ousted German troops from Pozsony (Bratislava), they interned Esterházy, but released him after 12 days. He later negotiated with Gustáv Husák who represented the interim Slovak government, and complained about the persecution of ethnic Hungarians. On the order of Husák he was arrested and handed over to the Soviet secret service KGB. He was kept for one year in the feared Lubyanka prison in Moscow, and then, on the basis of fabricated allegations, he was sentenced to ten years work in Siberia. The Slovak National Court in Bratislava on September 16, 1947 sentenced him in his absence to death for alleged collaboration with fascism. In 1949 the Soviet Union extradited him to Czechoslovakia. He was not executed as a presidential pardon commuted his sentence to life imprisonment. Over the next years he was transferred from prison to prison in Czechoslovakia. He died in Mírov prison in 1957.
Rehabilitation Denied
On January 21, 1993 the Russians rehabilitated János Esterházy. Under the seal of the Office of the Attorney General and the IG of the Armed Forces and signed by N. Sz. Vlaszenko, (document #Sz.: Zuv-9563-54) the order states in part that:
“It is hereby certified that János Esterházy, citizen of Czechoslovakia, born in Újlak in 1901, was arrested without cause on June 27, 1945…..and sentenced to ten years in a labor camp…. János Esterházy was rehabilitated according to the Russian Federation’s “Political Terror Victim’s Rehabilitation Act” of October 18, 1991, paragraphs 3 and 5….”
Slovakia still refuses to rehabilitate Esterhazy. But it enacted it’s Slovak Language Law and confirmed the outrageous Benes Decrees. Renowned Nazi-hunter, Simon Wiesenthal wrote a letter to Dr. Peter Samko, chief judge of the City of Pozsony (Bratislava), (published in the newspaper of Új Szó, 1993) in which he strongly defends Esterházy and offers witnesses on his behalf. Janos Eesterhazy was one of many Hungarians who spoke out against the Nazi threat.

Why So Many Hungarians Across the Border?

The Treaty of Trianon in 1920… in the aftermath of WWI, was extremely harsh on Hungary and unjustifiably one-sided. The resulting “treaty” lost Hungary an unprecedented 2/3 of her territory, and 1/2 of her total population or 1/3 of her Hungarian-speaking population. Add to this the loss of up to 90% of vast natural resources, industry, railways, and other infrastructure.
Additional Links
- AHF urges Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to “publicly and unambiguously express [her] concern relative to the Slovak language law
- AHF calls upon Vice President Biden to discuss Slovakia’s language law with Hungarian Prime Minister Bajnai
- AHF Submits Letter Regarding Intolerance in Slovakia
- Use of Hungarian ILLEGAL in Slovakia – Hungarian FM expresses regret
- Slovaks Confirm Benes Decrees: Called “Cancer of the Slovak Nation.” AHF issues statement.
- The Benes Decrees – a shameful act of ethnic cleansing
- The American Hungarian Federation’s call for greater cooperation among Hungarian American organizations in raising the ill-advised and discriminatory Slovak language law published in Heti Valasz
- “Halál a magyarokra!” / “Hunok a gázkamrába! Magyarok a Dunába!“
- 168 Óra Online írása: A ‘Halál a magyarokra’ Amerikában is kiverte a biztosítékot
- Amerikai magyar szervezet küldött levelet Kubišnak
- The Treaty of Trianon – A Nation Dismembered
- Vojvodina – More ethnic cleansing in historic Vajdasag
- News from Rumania – Home to the largest Hungarian “minority”
- Hungarian National Flags fly again in Hungarian churches in today’s Slovakia
- AHF Supporting Dual Citizenship
They are home in the sense that they, as communities, haven’t moved anywhere. They just woke up one morning to be told: “You are now a Czechoslovak, you are a Romanian, you are a Yugoslav.” This first happened in 1918-20, when Hungary was partitioned by the infamous Trianon Treaty, which was not a treaty at all, but a diktat enforced by occupying Entente Armies. In the late 1930’s, Hungary got some portions of its territories back, but after losing yet another war, the borders were tightened even more in 1947.
